Executive presence is a critical component of effective leadership. It enables leaders to command respect, foster trust, and amplify their influence. The Bates Model of Executive Presence (ExPI™) breaks down this concept into 15 observable behaviors across Character, Substance, and Style. Among these, confidence and assertiveness are particularly crucial for leaders who aim to inspire and guide their teams. This article explores how these traits can be developed through the Growth Mindset and insights from Manfred Kets de Vries’ INSEAD white paper, The Golden Larva Syndrome: Moving from Self-Sabotage to Self-Actualization, enhancing the understanding provided by the Bates Model.
The Bates Model of Executive Presence: A Closer Look
The Bates ExPI™ framework goes beyond superficial qualities like charisma to emphasize deeper, behavior-based aspects of leadership. It categorizes executive presence into three main dimensions:
Character: This dimension reflects the leader’s core values, emotional disposition, and beliefs. It includes qualities like authenticity, integrity, and humility—all of which are essential for building trust and credibility. Confidence is a key component of this dimension, representing a leader’s ability to project self-assurance and decisiveness.
Substance: This dimension relates to the leader’s knowledge, wisdom, and ability to inspire confidence in others. Leaders with strong substance are perceived as knowledgeable and composed. The development of confidence often stems from demonstrated expertise and consistent application of sound judgment.
Style: This involves how a leader engages and communicates with others. Assertiveness falls under this category, emphasizing the importance of speaking up and navigating conflicts constructively. Assertiveness ensures that leaders can express their ideas clearly and inspire collaboration without overpowering others.
The Bates Model underscores that executive presence is shaped not just by how leaders see themselves, but by how they are perceived by those they lead. Leaders must understand the gap between their intentions and the external perception of their actions.
Bates ExPI Executive Presence model
Growth Mindset: The Key to Unlocking Potential
The Growth Mindset, a concept developed by psychologist Carol Dweck, asserts that intelligence and abilities can be cultivated through effort, learning, and resilience. Leaders who embody a growth mindset are more likely to embrace challenges, persist through setbacks, and view criticism as an opportunity for growth. This mindset directly supports the development of confidence and assertiveness by encouraging leaders to learn from their experiences and strive for continuous improvement.
The Benefits of a Growth Mindset for Leaders:
Enhanced Resilience: Leaders with a growth mindset are better equipped to handle obstacles and failures. They see setbacks not as personal shortcomings but as opportunities to learn and adapt.
Increased Openness to Feedback: A growth mindset makes leaders more receptive to feedback, seeing it as valuable input for development rather than as criticism. This openness reinforces both confidence and assertiveness as leaders integrate constructive insights into their leadership practices.
Improved Problem-Solving: Leaders who believe in their capacity to grow are more willing to tackle complex problems and take calculated risks. This proactive approach strengthens their presence and decision-making abilities.
Example of Practice: Satya Nadella, CEO of Microsoft, exemplified the growth mindset when he transformed the company's culture from a “know-it-all” to a “learn-it-all” approach. This cultural shift encouraged employees to experiment and learn without fearing failure. Nadella’s confident, assertive communication style reflected this mindset and strengthened his executive presence.
Overcoming Psychological Barriers: Insights from The Golden Larva Syndrome
In his INSEAD white paper, The Golden Larva Syndrome: Moving from Self-Sabotage to Self-Actualization, Manfred Kets de Vries explores how self-sabotaging behaviors prevent leaders from reaching their full potential. These behaviors are often driven by psychological barriers such as fear of failure, fear of success, and impostor syndrome, which can diminish confidence and assertiveness.
1. Fear of Failure: This fear leads leaders to avoid risks, resulting in stagnation. A growth mindset can help leaders reframe failure as a learning experience, reducing the paralyzing effect of potential mistakes. When leaders embrace failure as part of the process, they build resilience and confidence.
2. Fear of Success: Leaders may avoid pursuing success due to the increased expectations and pressure it brings. This can result in procrastination or self-sabotage. Leaders who adopt a growth mindset see success as an opportunity to develop further, recognizing that they are capable of meeting new challenges.
3. Impostor Syndrome: Many accomplished leaders experience feelings of inadequacy, doubting their achievements and fearing exposure as frauds. Kets de Vries emphasizes that recognizing and addressing these beliefs is crucial for developing assertiveness and confidence. Leaders can counter impostor syndrome by seeking objective feedback, celebrating their successes, and acknowledging their contributions.
Real-World Example: Leveraging Coaching for Leadership Growth
Consider a senior director at a global technology company who was promoted to an executive role requiring regular communication with senior leadership teams. Despite having technical expertise and a solid track record, this leader struggled with confidence and assertiveness in high-stakes meetings due to underlying fears of failure and success.
Engaging in Executive Coaching: The director participated in an executive coaching program and completed the Bates ExPI™ 360-degree assessment. The feedback identified key areas for growth in confidence and assertiveness. With the support of an executive coach, the leader reflected on their psychological barriers and embraced a growth mindset, reframing challenges as opportunities for growth.
Action Plan and Results: Through targeted role-playing, visualization techniques, and incremental goal-setting, the leader practiced assertive communication. Over several months, their confidence improved, enabling them to contribute more effectively in meetings and gain recognition for their insights. Follow-up assessments indicated significant progress in perceived executive presence.
Practical Strategies for Cultivating a Growth Mindset
1. Foster a Learning-Oriented Environment: Leaders should model continuous learning by seeking knowledge and sharing experiences with their teams. This not only reinforces their own growth mindset but encourages their teams to adopt the same approach.
2. Reflect on Strengths and Growth Areas: Regular self-reflection allows leaders to understand their strengths and identify areas for development. Documenting daily achievements and challenges can build self-awareness and track progress over time.
3. Embrace Constructive Feedback: Leaders with a growth mindset value feedback as a tool for improvement. Engaging with multi-rater feedback tools like the Bates ExPI™ helps leaders gain insights into their leadership impact and refine their practices.
4. Practice Assertive Communication: Role-playing challenging conversations with peers or mentors can help leaders build comfort in expressing their ideas and opinions confidently.
5. Visualize Success: Visualizing positive outcomes before important meetings or interactions helps leaders reduce anxiety and approach situations with greater confidence.
6. Set Incremental Goals: Breaking down larger objectives into smaller, achievable tasks enables leaders to celebrate progress and build confidence incrementally.
7. Cultivate Self-Compassion: According to Brené Brown’s research on vulnerability, self-compassion fosters resilience and confidence. Leaders who treat themselves with kindness after setbacks are better equipped to recover quickly and maintain their assertiveness.
Impact on Team Dynamics and Culture
Leaders who embody confidence and assertiveness influence their teams and organizations positively. By modeling a growth mindset, leaders create a culture where team members feel empowered to share ideas, take calculated risks, and engage in collective problem-solving. Howard Schultz, former CEO of Starbucks, exemplified this when he made bold strategic decisions that reinforced trust and collaboration within the company.
Integrating the Growth Mindset, Bates Model, and Kets de Vries' Insights
Combining the growth mindset with the Bates Model of Executive Presence and insights from The Golden Larva Syndrome provides a robust framework for leadership development. Leaders can identify internal barriers, embrace new mindsets, and use feedback to build confidence and assertiveness, reinforcing their executive presence and impact.
Check my PodCast EPISODE #5 Leadership Insights Coffee Chat
A Path to Authentic and Impactful Leadership
Confidence and assertiveness are key to building a compelling executive presence. By addressing psychological barriers, adopting a growth mindset, and leveraging structured feedback, leaders can transform their potential into real influence. The journey to authentic leadership is continuous, but with dedication, reflection, and practice, leaders can cultivate a legacy of trust, resilience, and excellence.